Index Mathematics Conjectures nbv lettuce Widgets

A mostly rational analysis of existence, distinguishability, and notation in discrete algebra involving information.

Treatise of bra-ket notation in quantum algebra

Bra-ket notation is the standard language for expressing quantum systems symbolically. This notation is used to bridge vectors of real elements to and from the complex space, and to support operations across and between vectors of variable dimension. Although this may be convenient for analysis of symbolically large or dense logic, the additional symbols introduce artificial complexity to the symbolic representation of systems, which in turns shapes the reasoning about such systems. Any change to the reasoning about the axioms of reality is tautologically suspect.1

A separate, distinct, issue is the lack of representation of quantum variables. We draw the distinction between the imaginary set ℂ, values which do not exist in this reality, but may exist in other realities; and the quantum set e̸, values which exist in no reality. e.g. although −1 has no concrete value in this reality, there may be non-euclidean realities or otherwise unexplainable, unknowable, or coincidental resolutions to a concrete value. We draw a distinction between values which could theoretically be represented, and values which information theoretically preclude representation, giving this set the unique axiom: e̸=e̸∈ℂ. Quantum values are indistinguishable except by relativity.

Tightening the description from the previous writing, define the quantum set e̸: values which are a ratio between two distinct values, each containing an infinite amount of information. The previous writing made a weaker statement: “the ratio of two irrationals”, but for a value to be unrepresentable it must be the output of a program taking as input two or more distinct variables, each with an infinite amount of information. Although characterizing a concrete quantum value is, by definition, nonsensical, we attempt to illustrate the notion with the value: eπ. This value requires a complexity space to compute (a program), and contains two distinct infinite amounts of information 2 , precluding representation in a reality with no complexity space (an information-theoretically immutable reality). The preclusion of representation in an immutable reality is not by size, but by lack of information: it is impossible to select the reality containing exactly eπ because the concrete value is unknowable (as opposed to e or π which are known by an immutable reality and thus symbolically representable). Conceptually one might consider the reality where only the ratio of a circle to its radius exists.3

Given the quantum set we can symbolically represent information which is not known in any reality. Applied to a 2-dimensional discrete linear algebra we have: z̸,z=aX∈ℤqkwithq<∞andk>0

Crucially, quantum values do not exist in continuous algebra. Any set with an infinite number of values allows concrete representations in an infinite number of alternate realities by congruence.4 Conversely, an operation in a discrete space physically discards information by forming an algebra over an infinite space as a congruence to a finite space. By definition operations in such a space are existentially distinct because the discarded information can only be known to the observer, not the system itself. That is, the result of a program operating on variables in a discrete finite space has information which is physically unrepresentable in the output: the congruences of all intermediate values in the real space.

Contrast this with a program in the real space: such a program can always be logically identified by symbolically adding a shim which tracks a list of intermediate values. The equivalent in a discrete space is an argument of knowledge: an algebraically distinct fingerprint for the existence of the run of a program. This illustrates the quantum space e̸ as a probability space: the probability that a vector of finite length has no pairwise distinct entries (all elements are equal). No vector containing a quantum value can be identically equal to another vector.

By further contrast, a vector containing quantum values and non-quantum values has a minimum pairwise distinct cardinality equal to the cardinality of quantum values plus one: |e̸|+1. 5 This is the emergent symbolic split z,z̸, because the relative position of quantum and non-quantum values in a vector is irrelevant for identity comparison purposes. This is an emergent property of e̸ being both a value and a set. e.g. it splits a vector into a totally ordered set of real vectors, and quantum vectors. If the position-wise distribution of quantum values is normal it forms a low dimension object like a matrix. The amount of information in the structural distribution of quantum and real values determines the dimension of the hypercube formed by the run of a program.

Logically, because entropy exists, it is impossible to represent physics symbolically using continuous mathematics. e̸ is an abstract algebraic symbol representing the dimension of the information lost. The dimension defines the value because information has 0 mass. This value should then be observed for algebraic consistency, and to determine the dimension changes of thermodynamic processes. This may yield interesting interactions between information and physics beyond induction of behavior in intelligences.

notes

Consider a function mapping e̸k→e̸. Because values are identically incomparable, there exist no two functions f(e̸k)→e̸ and g(e̸k)→e̸ such that f≠g. Put differently, all functions that are the same shape are equal. This implies that indistinguishability obfuscation could be achieved by tracking a constant size simulation of an e̸ term. This would be a quantum program of complexity 𝒪︀(1) being run on a single qubit simulation of a quantum computer on a classical computer. The immediately interesting subspace being quantum programs of time complexity 𝒪︀(1) and space complexity 𝒪︀(N).

Consider the vector space ℤ0. This space contains a single element: the empty set, ∅︀. However, ∅︀=∅︀∉ℂ and so the vector space e̸0 does not exist. This leads to an interesting conclusion: the set of things which do not exist can never be empty.

This explains why relativity holds without a z̸ term. In cases where no information is lost, e̸∈ℂ. In cases where information is lost we call this entropy but, to my understanding, do not symbolically express it, but rather approximate by observation. The e̸ symbol tracks the dimension of entropy.

  1. Reality shapes and defines mathematics, never the other way. ↩

  2. Conceptually each is taking the output of a program with z̸≠e̸ operating on information from our physical reality. ↩

  3. I swear I’m not crazy. ↩

  4. This is tough to reason about and a better statement can be made here. ↩

  5. All sets containing quantum elements are multisets. Decent argument of the set/multiset conjecture and explains cryptography. ↩